The IEEPA Tariff Refunds Series: The Forensic Accounting Pieces for the Tariff Refunds and Related Claims Puzzle

Part I of this series addressed how the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) tariff refunds are administered. Part II addressed whether refund payments will arrive, how much of the refund the company may be able to keep, and whether the company ultimately may owe some of the refunds to its customers or vendors. This third entry focuses on US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), what financial records establish, and whether analysis will support an investigation, disclosure assessment, or litigation position.
- For white-collar and trade counsel, inventory methods, cost allocations, and revenue recognition issues can materially change the IEEPA tariff refund amount, treatment, and potential liability disclosures.
- An experienced forensic accountant can trace who funded the duty, test whether tariffs explain price changes, and reconcile vendor and consumer claims without conflating accounting profit with legal entitlement, for internal accounting, litigation settlement, or expert testimony purposes.
- Counsel should engage appropriately licensed and credentialed forensic accounting professionals early, supported by data analytics and trade expertise, to evaluate competing theories, calculations, reporting risks, and proposed reimbursements—including whether and to what extent administrative deductions are supportable.
The Issue
Parts I and II of this IEEPA tariff refunds series addressed issues related to tariff recovery and competing claims to the proceeds. For white-collar and trade attorneys handling these matters, the next questions that should be considered relate to issues around internal and external accounting treatment and financial records.
A customs refund identifies a recovery; it does not, by itself, show how duties affected accounting related issues including, but not limited to, inventory, earnings, customer prices, or obligations to others. Those questions require tracing transactions across records and testing alternative accounting theories and principles. This is forensic accounting work: Working with counsel to reconstruct what happened, what the accounting records show, what assumptions and treatment were made, who made the decisions, and how those different records and treatments impact completeness, rights and obligations, valuation, accuracy, classification, and presentation—ultimately, the question of whether and how much may need to be refunded to customers.
Counsel should look for a forensic accounting team combining relevant CPA licensure, recognized forensic credentials, investigative and litigation experience, and the ability to explain and test its methodology. The following example shows why the work goes beyond merely allocating a refund total. The public cases discussed below involve allegations and defenses, but not findings.
A 50 Percent Markup: Who Gets the Additional $10?
A simplified example separates pricing from inventory accounting. A $100 cost with a 50 percent markup gives a $150 price and $50 gross profit. Adding a $20 tariff, with all other things being equal, raises cost to $120, price to $180, and gross profit to $60. The gross-margin percentage is 33.3 percent in both cases: the $10 difference is gross-profit dollars, not a change in that percentage.
Assume the unit was sold, the full $20 duty is recovered and recognized as a cost reduction, and customer reimbursements reduce net revenue. Ignoring interest, taxes, and other adjustments, the potential outcomes are as follows:
- No customer refund: The net revenue stays at $180, cost becomes $100, and gross profit becomes $80.
- A $20 customer refund: The net revenue becomes $160 and gross profit is $60. The duty is passed back, but the company retains the $10 incremental markup.
- A $30 customer refund: The net revenue becomes $150 and gross profit returns to $50. This reverses both the duty-driven price increase and the incremental markup.
As discussed in parts I and II, contracts, pricing representations, legal theories, and remedies determine entitlement. Yet, comparing these three treatments highlights the issue—in the first example, the company does not refund the customer and its gross profit increases from $50 to $80; in the second example, the company refunds to its customer the amount it was refunded from the government, or $20, but is able to retain the additional $10 in gross profit; in the third example, the company refunds both the government refund of $20 and the additional $10 gross profit that it “overcharged” the customer.
The single-unit example is simple, but the financial effects can grow quickly at retail scale. Pandora, for example, reported 2025 revenue of DKK32.5 billion and 112 million units sold, mainly jewelry but including other items such as gift boxes. Illustratively, a $1 to $20 difference across 10 million affected units produces $10 to $200 million; across 100 million affected units, a $10 difference reaches $1 billion. These are illustrative dollar sensitivities, not actual estimates of Pandora’s tariff exposure, refunds, or liabilities, and units sold are not distinct styles or SKUs. It is intended, instead, to highlight the importance of the company, counsel, and a strong forensic accounting team testing affected volumes, treatments, theories, and interacting assumptions, and then documenting the supporting rationale for each decision and treatment.
What Recent SEC Filings Show
Selected Forms 10-Q and 10-K filed between May 10, 2026, and November 10, 2026, illustrate differences in accounting recognition, presentation, and sharing arrangements among several companies. This targeted review is not intended to be exhaustive, and company-specific policies and facts are not universal accounting requirements or proof of customer rights.
Keysight used an ASC 405 legal-release approach for its $100 million refund receivable and separately recorded a $40 million customer liability. Meanwhile, Carter’s gain-contingency model left unadjudicated claims unrecognized.
Crown Crafts moved from no year-end receivable to recognizing accepted claims under a loss-recovery approach. UPS, meanwhile, reported received refunds awaiting customer pass-through in current liabilities, meaning UPS is reserving the cash it received so it does not necessarily represent money available to retain.
Designer Brands monetized claims and treated subsequent remittances as financing. Flexsteel quantified a 200-basis-point refund-related gross-margin benefit but warned of retailer, supplier, and distributor claims. Such financing costs and reimbursement obligations may affect the amount ultimately retained.
Thus, recognition, presentation, and sharing/potential liability can depend on more than whether a company expects to collect, how much it may collect, when it may collect, and whether pass through treatment is expected for some or all of the refund.
Refund interest adds another layer. Federal customs law generally requires the government to pay interest on excess duty deposits, and it compounds daily at quarterly rates.[i] In March, the US Court of International Trade estimated the IEEPA tariff refund accrual at approximately $650 million monthly, and US Customs and Border Protection’s (CBP) November 10 declaration reported $128.4 billion of duties plus interest sent to Treasury, without isolating interest. As an example, Lululemon separately disclosed $4.1 million of interest received along with its $134.5 million of refunds. In the example illustration above of various treatments, however, interest on the $20 recovery is distinct from the $10 markup, but whether a company may be on the hook to its customers for accrued interest on the additional $10 markup and/or any additional imputed accrued interest through the actual date of reimbursement/settlement is a question.
Forensic Accounting Issues Counsel Should Evaluate
For each issue, the company, counsel, and accounting/finance team should discuss legally and technically supportable alternatives, test their financial effects, and document the chosen approach and rationale. These are not unrestricted accounting elections and the implications on the various approaches can be significant.
Tracing Costs and Competing Claims
For trade counsel, customs eligibility starts the inquiry. A forensic accounting team can trace duties through costs, prices, and payments while counsel determines entitlement.
- Duty-to-transaction reconciliation. Before allocating the example’s $20, reconcile customs entries, inventory, and the general ledger. Specific identification, FIFO, LIFO, and weighted-average cost flows can produce different allocations; standard costing and retail inventory techniques add reconciliation questions. Distinguish sold and unsold units, variances, and write-downs. Accounting/finance and counsel should discuss the supported tracing approach and record limitations rather than assume every purchaser paid $30 more.
- Pricing and the additional $10. The 50 percent markup adds $10 of gross profit, not a higher initial gross-margin percentage. Was the $30 price increase actually tariff-driven? Compare pricing, promotions, sourcing, freight, and exchange rates by product, period, and channel. Stockov/Costco and Hoffert/Nintendo illustrate disputed pricing and attribution questions and why discussions of alternative no-tariff-price assumptions are necessary to have with the company, counsel, and finance.
- Who owns principal and interest—and who may be owed. The example’s $20 recovery—and any interest—may face competing customer, vendor, or assignee claims. CBP pays the importer of record or its properly designated recipient, but receipt does not settle ultimate ownership. Reiser/FedEx seeks duties and fees; Cycle Limited seeks an accounting of customer-funded duties. These are allegations, not established rights, that instead typically are dependent on language found in contracts, assignments, invoices, payments, and reimbursements. The company, counsel, and accounting/finance should discuss supportable reimbursement options and assess principal and interest separately.
- Overhead, administration, and contractual deductions. At a fixed 10 percent-of-material-cost rate assumption to the example above, allocated overhead decreases from $12 on $120 to $10 on $100, but actual costs may not be impacted. Fixed and variable overhead allocation, markup, processing costs, and professional fees, therefore, all may need separate analysis. Hence, discussing and agreeing on various supportable allocation and reimbursement approaches with accounting/finance and counsel should be performed.
Recognition, Earnings, and Disclosure
For white-collar counsel working with forensic accountants, claims, recognized assets, and cash should be distinguished and analyzed. Forensic chronologies and financial bridges can test reporting judgments without substituting hindsight or accounting profit for legal entitlement.
- Recognition, collectability, and policy consistency. When can the example’s $20 become a receivable or earnings benefit? Filing a claim is not enough. The company, counsel, and accounting/finance should discuss the applicable loss-recovery, gain-contingency, or other supported model, reporting-date evidence, payment conditions, and intermediary collectability.
- Government recovery, earnings, and retained benefit. A $20 cost reduction plus a $20 customer refund leaves $60 gross profit and a 37.5 percent margin in the sold-unit example, and unsold inventory may affect earnings later. Therefore, recoveries should be reconciled with inventory/COGS, revenue reductions, liabilities, interest, financing, and tax. Furthermore, different reimbursement scenarios and presentation should be discussed with counsel and accounting/finance, separating recognized obligations from disputed claims, and interest’s accrual timing, presentation, and pass-through liabilities should be tested and calculated.
- Earnings management, one-time benefits, and disclosure risks. Could the $20 recovery improperly boost earnings through premature or duplicate recognition, unsupported timing/classification changes, understated liabilities, or selective adjustments to meet targets? Counsel and accounting/finance should test entries and discuss required disclosures of material one-time benefits, uncertainty, and reimbursement risks, including reconciling GAAP, non-GAAP, and incentive measures. Legitimate earnings benefits are not misconduct, and the example’s $10 is not inherently nonrecurring, yet misleading reporting often prompts shareholder claims or SEC enforcement. In fact, ProPublica reported on November 16, 2026, that at least nine public companies disclosed using at least part of its IEEPA refund for incentive pay and bonuses for executives, and several US senators have asked the FTC to investigate, which may prompt even more scrutiny and litigation.
Investigations, Damages, and Other Issues
Counsel sets the legal theory, and forensic professionals test the evidence and quantify alternatives. The analysis should identify its sources, assumptions, and limitations so counsel can assess its strengths and vulnerabilities.
- Controls, communications, and whistleblowers. Do communications and approvals support—or contradict—the treatment of the $20 recovery and customer obligations? To answer this question, an analysis of entries, disclosures, and commitments for premature recognition, inflated revenue, suppressed liabilities, or withheld refunds must be performed without presuming wrongdoing. Counsel, the company, and accounting/finance should evaluate exceptions, litigation implications, remediation, and document decisions and rationale. Misconduct can lead to restatements, sanctions, penalties, fines, and litigation.
- Reproducible damages and expert challenge. Counsel should select the liability theory, while the company and financial specialists discuss supported assumptions, offsets, and data limitations. These theories should then be tested across products, periods, and channels and reconcile overlapping claims.
- Other issues. Depending on the company and specific facts, fixed-asset basis/depreciation; impairment and deferred-tax realizability; income tax, including section 451(b); classification, interest, and subsequent events; assignments, financing, and derivatives; liquidity, covenants, offsets, and measurement dates may also need to be taken into consideration.
Implications for Counsel and Case Strategy
Before making refund calculations, advising on disclosures, reimbursing customers, or developing expert opinions, reviewing the relevant customs records, financial data, pricing decisions, and communications is essential for any company dealing with IEEPA refund and litigation issues. Transactions should be reconciled to the company’s books, key assumptions documented, and how different assumptions affect the results should be evaluated since the impacts could be substantial.
Counsel, therefore, should work with company finance, tax, and operations teams and engage appropriately licensed CPAs, credentialed forensic accountants, data analysts, and trade specialists as needed. These professionals establish the financial facts and evaluate alternative calculations, while counsel directs legal strategy.
How BRG Can Help
BRG’s multidisciplinary professionals combine CPA licensure and CFF/CFE credentials, doctoral expertise in trade economics and damages, forensic data analytics and AI-enabled analysis, and senior federal trade-policy experience, including former Department of Homeland Security leadership. Working with company finance teams and counsel, BRG can trace costs and refunds, test pricing and accounting assumptions, evaluate disclosures and competing damages models, and support expert reports and testimony.
[i] See, 19 USC §1505—payment and interest; CBP IEEPA Duty Refunds; 19 CFR §24.36—refund-interest rules; and 26 CFR §301.6622-1—daily compounding.
Authors
Related Industries

Prepare for what's next.
ThinkSet magazine, a BRG publication, provides nuanced, multifaceted thinking and expert guidance that help today’s business leaders adopt a more strategic, long-term mindset to prepare for what’s next.



